Drilled tank

[SunnyHouTX]

Herbie and Stockman

[ssrprelude]

Yeah MJ's setup is silent!

[moganman]

I need a thorough tutorial of how this thing works one day.

[fishman1]

just get a drilled one if you dont like it you can always plug it up

[myjohnson]

Herbie and Stockman

Nahhh, I've done both and herbie punks stockman. Herbie is literally silent.

[SunnyHouTX]

Of the two, no doubt Herbie is silent-er but Stockman works as well where you can't get a Herbie going.

[myjohnson]

Stockman is OK.

I assume you have your tanks set up this way.

Do you hear a lot of noise from water hitting the sump?

[SunnyHouTX]

Not really.

[moganman]

Herbie and Stockman?????

[eklikewhoa]

IMO, herbie overflow will take up a lot of footprint real estate and if you just run a low flow return pump it would make little to no noise with a well built stockman.

[SunnyHouTX]

IMO, herbie overflow will take up a lot of footprint real estate and if you just run a low flow return pump it would make little to no noise with a well built stockman.

+1.

I have a Mag 12 being fed by a dual overflow HOB with two Stockmans that's very quiet.