Eheim 2217 vs Rena Filstar Px3...need imput

[MichelleRenee68]

I just set up a 140 gallon Cichlid aquarium and am now looking to upgrade my filter/pump.

I am looking at the RENA Filstar px3 and the EHEIM 2217. Which in your opinion is the better of the 2?

I had both in the past in 75 gal tanks (different models) and liked both of them but now that I am moving to a bigger tank, I need to know which is the better for the 140gal

Thanks,
Michelle

[aggrofishkeeper]

Eheim all day!

[MichelleRenee68]

That's what I was thinking as well but thought I would get another opinion. Thanks!

[Totenkampf]

is there a PX3 filter or is that the XP3? i responded in your other post...

[Nelson]

Eheim IMO is better and quiet 99%, I sometimes have to touch it to make sure its working, I guess I'm not the only one that do that.


Eheim :Best
Rena : Better

[TexSun]

I'm running seven eheim classics right now. That's gotta say something...