New Member Reputation feature

[imagirlgeek]

Can members have negative Points?

Yes.

[Bogdan]

Yes, I got it. I am pretty sure your intentions are very good. It's just sometimes/often in the reality the results are far from the anticipated. I hope I am wrong.

[CichlidFan]

I appreciate the work and passion that has gone into improving the box Traci, but I have to hang with bogdan on this one.

I believe this feature will promote "classes" or if you will pardon the conspriacy talk here, this feature could and probably will promote "elite" users on the box.

For those who enjoy the thrill of receiving gold stars from the teacher, or in this case, their fellow box members, then, what the heck.....

For those who cannot accept critical review of their comments, then this feature will need a teaspoon of sugar to help the medicine go down.

Do I get any rep points for my comment? )

CF

[Delock]

"will promote "elite" users on the box."

Man...you owe me a monitor. I spit out my sprite on my second monitor when I saw this.

[eklikewhoa]

I agree with most of the above... it could work both ways and probably more in favor of those that are "liked".

I tend to add my opinions strongly with the advice I give and as many have said it does not sit will with most reciepiants, now though my advice in most cases are solid my opinion added negates it to some members.... this would then "deem" my comment as negative.

I vote "I don't care".

[imagirlgeek]

This was obviously a bad call on my part. There was significant concern that this was a popularity contest, so I've turned it off.